In the New Government Resolution (GR) Issued on Tuesday, The State Government Removed the Word “Mandatory”, but because of the restrictive conditions on alternatives to hindi as a third as a aer than a lot of people. Push ”for Hindi. Howver, the state government still insists Hindi is just an “optional” language.

What is this new gr, and how is it different?

The new gr is a revision of the earler orders that said about the words The established practice for these schools in maharashtra has been to introduce a third language to student in secondary school or after class 5.

The order was withdrawn after criticism from political parties and education experts, and an assurance was given that a new resolution would be issued to clarify that hindi will just be an “Operation” as a thirty languagge.

The latest gr states, “Hindi will be generally be the third language for classes 1 to 5.” If students wish to “Study Other Indian Language Instad of Hindi As their third language” Particular language ”.

If not, the gr says, “Language will be taught through online methods”.

What questions do it raise?

The inclusion of the word “generally” has sparked fresh criticism. The revised order, according to the critics, fails to provide any options or alternatives to Hindi apart from Stating that it has to be an Indian language. They say that there are multiple indian languages ​​and the state has to clarify what can be taught and define the curriculum.

Educationist Kishore Darak Also Identified the Need for a structured curriculum for thirt. “Teaching pedagogies for language are different. The assumption is that those who can teachi can teachi hindi … the script of the two languages ​​is similar but that does not mean no exra epic. Teachers in terms of learning, “He said.

Teachers have also questioned how the government plan to make arrangements for students when they want to study an alternative language. Some have even raised objections about the need for 20 students per class as a prerequisite to studying another language.

Senior Educationist Vascant Kalpande Said that “Over 80% Government-Run Schools” In Maharashtra would not be avle to meet the criteria, thereby automatically making Hindi the default Third Language.

“A lot of government-run schools have a total enrollment than 20 students in a class. Languages), No Government-Run School Will Be Able To Provide An Option To Hindi, “Kalpande Said.

Girish Samant, The Chairman of the Shikshan Mandal Goregaon, which runs a popular marathi medium school in suburban mumbai, flagged issue with the direction on online teaching. “This is very unclear as the government is asking schools to see online platforms to teach languages ​​alternative to hindi without providing a curriculum, textbooks or any other suport. The government does not justify how language can be taught online to class 1 student. “

What is the government said?

After the revised G sparked a heated debate, state school education minister dada bhuse issued a clarification on wednesday equiving.

“Marathi will be a compulsory subject in all schools, regardless of the medium of instruction. Marathi.

An official from the School Education Department Said Detailed Guidelines would be issued soon on alternatives to Hindi.

How have other parties reacted?

After the original order was issued in april, Maharastra Navnirman Sena (Mns) President Raj Thackeray Took The most agresive stand on the issue, joined by his own and Shiv Seena (Ubt) CHIEVDDDHACE. The state congress, too, joined the regional parties to staunchly oppose the allegation imposition of hindi in state schools.

The mns, whose core plank is built around Marathi Identity Politics, has again strongly criticized the new gr and warned that Such Threatens the cultural and linguistic identity of the state.

“Why is Hindi being forced only in maharastra? Raj Thackery Asked At a Press Conference on Wednesday. The Mns Chief has also written to school principals, advising them against implementing the order.

The congress targeted the government, said the latter “was mely playing with words”. “This is a part of the RSS’s strategy of imposing hindi on all regions and destroying the regional culture,” Alleged Maharashtra Congress Chief Harshvardhan Sapkal.

Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis has said the three-Language formula is as per the recommendation of the new education policy (NEP). “We are backing English but Hating Indian Languages. Steudents.